Wigdor LLP represented Rod Wheeler, a paid contributor at Fox News, against 21st Century Fox, the Fox News Network, reporter Malia Zimmerman, and contributor Ed Butowsky. The Complaint alleged that Zimmerman, Butowsky and Fox had colluded with the Trump Administration to disseminate fake news in order to divert attention away from Russia’s alleged attempts to influence the United States Presidential election.
The Complaint alleged that Mr. Wheeler, a former Washington D.C. homicide detective who now works as a private investigation consultant, was subjected to defamation when Fox, Zimmerman and Butowsky published a May 16, 2017 article that included two fabricated quotations, both of which were falsely attributed to Mr. Wheeler. The article, written by Zimmerman, reported that a murdered Democratic National Committee (“DNC”) staffer, Seth Rich, was the source of the DNC emails leaked by Wikileaks during the 2016 Presidential primaries. Fox retracted the article on May 23, 2017.
According to the Complaint, the motivation behind the article was to establish that Seth Rich provided Wikileaks with the DNC emails in order to shift the blame from Russia and to help dispel speculation that President Trump colluded with Russia in an attempt to influence the outcome of the Presidential election. The two quotes, falsely attributed to Mr. Wheeler, stated:
- “‘My investigation up to this point shows there was some degree of email exchange between Seth Rich and Wikileaks,’ said Wheeler.”
- “‘My investigation shows someone within the DC government, Democratic National Committee or Clinton team is blocking the murder investigation from going forward,’ Wheeler said. ‘That is unfortunate. Seth Rich’s murder is unsolved as a result of that.’”
As set forth in the Complaint, according to Butowsky, the statements were falsely attributed to Wheeler because that is the way the President wanted the article. The Complaint alleged that Trump’s press secretary Sean Spicer met with Wheeler and Butowsky at the White House to review the Rich story a month before it was published. Butowsky also texted Wheeler: “Not to add any more pressure but the president just read the article. He wants the article out immediately. It’s now all up to you.” Moreover, he left a voicemail telling Wheeler “the White House is onto this now.”
Interestingly, according to the Complaint, at the same time that Fox was helping the Trump Administration divert public attention from the Russian hacking scandal, 21st Century Fox’s General Counsel, Gerson Zweifach, was meeting with UK regulators in an attempt to convince them that Fox was “fit and proper” to purchase Sky, the British media conglomerate, despite the attenuating power to influence the news agenda and the political process. In addition, according to the British regulator Ofcom’s report, on May 15, 2017, the day before the article in question was published, Fox promulgated a new compliance arrangement to meet the Broadcasting Code.
Plaintiff was represented by Wigdor LLP Partners Douglas H. Wigdor and Jeanne M. Christensen, and Senior Associate Michael J. Willemin. Douglas Wigdor said of the filing:
“Rod Wheeler unfortunately was used as a pawn by Ed Butowsky, Fox News and the Trump administration to try and steer away the attention that was being given about the Russian hacking of the DNC e-mails.”
Douglas Wigdor’s Interview with “NPR – Morning Edition”
August 1, 2017
NPR
“Behind Fox News’ Baseless Seth Rich Story: The Untold Tale”
Read PDF
Read Online
CNN
“Lawsuit: Fox News concocted Seth Rich story with oversight from White House”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Huffington Post
“Trump Linked To Fox News’ Bogus Seth Rich Story, Lawsuit Alleges”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
New York Times
“Lawsuit Asserts White House Role in Fox News Article on Seth Rich”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Washington Post
“Lawsuit alleges Fox News made up part of Seth Rich story”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Law360
“Trump Urged On Fake Fox News Story, Defamation Suit Says”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Vanity Fair
“White House Pushed Fox News to Publish Seth Rich Story, Lawsuit
Claims”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Bloomberg
“Trump Worked with Fox News on DNC Staffer Story, Suit Claims”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Daily Mail
“BREAKING NEWS: President Trump pressured Fox News to release fake story about death of DNC staffer Seth Rich and Wikileaks to divert attention from Russia, claims explosive lawsuit”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Newsweek
“Seth Rich Lawsuit Claims White House Colluded With Fox News to Fake Story on DNC Staffer”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Daily Beast
“Trump Told Fox News to Frame Dems for Seth Rich Murder, Lawsuit Claims”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
New York Law Journal
“Lawyer in Seth Rich Suit Insists Politics Played No Part in Fox,
Trump Claims”
August 2, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
The Guardian
“The strange case of Fox News, Trump, and the death of young Democrat Seth Rich”
August 7, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
NY Times
“Fox Is Said to Have Declined to Settle Suits for $60 Million”
August 8, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
NY Business Journal
“Fox refuses to pay $60 million in settlements”
August 9, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
Business Insider
“A law firm leading several cases against Fox News is trying to torpedo the $15 billion Fox-Sky merger”
August 8, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
Variety
“Fox News Headlines Muddy 21st Century’s Bid for Sky”
August 9, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
New York Times
“Fox Presses for Arbitration or Dismissal in Suit Over Seth Rich Article”
September 19, 2017
Read PDF
Read OnlineNew York Law Journal
“Lawsuit Claims Fox News, Trump Conspired on DNC Staffer
Murder Story”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
New York Post
“Fox News accused of making up quotes in DNC murder story”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Above the Law
“Lawsuit Claims Trump, Fox Conspired To Produce Fake News About
Seth Rich”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
USA Today
“Suit: Fox News, White House collaborated on fake news story in Seth
Rich death”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
ABC News
“WH reviewed Fox News story about Seth Rich before publication, lawsuit alleges”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
NBC News
“Fox News allegedly made fake news to protect Trump”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
The Hill
“Lawsuit claims Trump involvement in retracted Fox story on Seth Rich”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Newsday
“Lawsuit: Fox made up part of story, worked with White House”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Telegraph
“Donald Trump ‘collaborated with Fox News’ on fake story about death
of DNC staffer, claims lawsuit”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Slate
“Lawsuit Alleges the White House Helped Fox News Push the Seth Rich
Conspiracy Theory”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Politico
“Lawsuit says Fox knowingly faked Seth Rich story”
August 1, 2017
Read PDF
Read Online
Newsweek
“Seth Rich suit lawyer wants Trump and Sean Spicer to give evidence in case against Fox News”
August 2, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
Huffington Post
“Rod Wheeler, Fox News, Donald Trump, And The Ghost Of Seth Rich”
August 9, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
LA Times
“Fox News’ handling of Seth Rich story could snag British review of Sky deal”
August 8, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
The Guardian
“Fox News story sparks calls for further scrutiny of Murdoch’s Sky bid”
August 7, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
The Daily Beast
“Fox News’ Fake News Could Doom Rupert Murdoch’s Dream”
August 7, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
The Wrap
“Attorney Tries to Stop 21st Century’s Fox Bid to Takeover Sky News”
August 7, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF
Above The Law
“Fire, Fury, and Fox News”
August 11, 2017
Read Online
Read PDF